The Pre-Arrest Remedy: Rethinking Anticipatory Bail

Ismat Mahmudha Karim Maisha: Pre-arrest or anticipatory bail has come into existence as an important judicial tool in resolving this problem. Anticipatory bail in Bangladesh has its own distinct nature in terms of law. The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 does not have any statutory provision at present that explicitly recognizes anticipatory bail. While Section 497A was inserted in 1978, it was then repealed. However, Section 498 CrPC gives the High Court Division and Court of Session very wide powers to admit an accused person to bail in any case even when he or she is charged with a non-bailable offence.
The underlying reason for anticipatory bail, however, is not an assurance of exemption from the criminal process. Instead, anticipatory bail is concerned with the prevention of an illegal and oppressive arrest in situations where the protection of the judiciary can be claimed. The distinction is crucial in that one should not be considered guilty solely on the basis of allegations being made against them.On the other hand, it is also clear that mere apprehension of arrest will not qualify for anticipatory bail. As stated by the High Court Division, there needs to be a reasonable fear of arrest in specific circumstances. Merely being apprehensive is not enough.
The main issue in cases of anticipatory bail is striking a proper balance between personal liberty and efficient criminal investigation. The grant of protection against arrest may protect a person from unwarranted detention; however, an unlimited grant of protection may affect investigations if the accused tries to influence witnesses, tamper with the evidence, or evades proper investigation procedures. In this regard, the Supreme Court has reiterated the need for courts to exercise extreme care since there may be an interference to some extent with the investigation process in cases of anticipatory bail. It is necessary that the applicant granted protection works in coordination with the investigating officer. The issues that have to be taken into consideration include the nature of the accusations, the materials available to the court, the involvement of the accused, the likelihood of running away, and the likelihood of influencing witnesses or obstructing investigation.
At the time of granting anticipatory bail, it is the requirement of law that the accused must be present before the court and the court being satisfied that accused is not fugitive from justice can grant anticipatory bail. If a fugitive surrenders before the High Court Division and prays for bail, it may either grant bail under section 498 CrPC, or is obliged to hand him or her over to the police, to be dealt with in accordance with law.
Among the significant milestones in the anticipatory-bail jurisprudence of Bangladesh, one must note the time period for which this protection can be provided. The Appellate Division has ruled that the period of such protection ought not to exceed eight weeks and that such protection will end when the charge sheet is filed. A decision was handed down in March 2024 by the Appellate Division wherein an order that had granted the benefit of anticipatory bail until the filing of the police report was modified and the Court ordered that the respondents continue on bail for eight weeks and thereafter surrender before the proper court.
Anticipatory bail being an extraordinary remedy, judicial discretion needs to be exercised with utmost care and uniformity. The Appellate Division has condemned the arbitrary and mechanical granting of anticipatory bail and pointed out that the High Court Division should exercise its discretion within the ambit of law. In other words, rethinking anticipatory bail does not necessarily entail either narrowing or widening of the scope of this remedy. Rather, it entails exploring ways in which this remedy can work in a more orderly manner.
Anticipatory bail holds a significant place in the interface between individual liberty and criminal justice. The evolution of anticipatory bail in Bangladesh is a classic illustration of the effort made by the judiciary to provide protection to individuals against arbitrary arrest while ensuring the efficiency of criminal investigations. The current concept places stress on reasonable suspicion, special circumstances, judicial review, facilitation of investigation, suitable conditions, and temporary nature of anticipatory bail. This suggests that anticipatory bail must be considered as a well-regulated pre-arrest procedure rather than an absolute protection against criminal prosecution. Finally, the eternal problem remains one of striking a balanced course between the two – individual liberty vs. criminal investigation. Thus, rethinking anticipatory bail is not only reconsidering the procedural device, but constantly establishing the proper bounds of State powers in a legal framework committed to justice and liberty.



